Gourmet Pizza - Best of 2012

Published Apr 10, 2012

Inventive toppings, fresh ingredients, and hand-made crust, that's the kind of pizza we're talking about. What's your favorite slice?

Winner
2012 Winner

1. Melo's Pizza and Pasta

Voters Love

"I've been going to Melo's in Pleasant Hill for years, so when I heard one was opening near my work in Livermore, I was..." via thenotoriousgap

Find It
Multiple Locations
  • Melo's Pizza and Pasta, Livermore, Cheap Eats, Wine Country, Food, Great Meals, Livermore Family Restaurant, Pizza, Wine Country Family Restaurant, Place for Greasy Slice, Gourmet Pizza, 4433 First Street Livermore CA 94551
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    Multiple locations
  • Brothers Pizza, Food, Great Meals, Gourmet Pizza, Place for a Slice, 3627 Taraval Street Outer Sunset San Francisco CA 94116
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    3627 Taraval Street, Outer Sunset San Francisco, CA
  • Multiple locations
  • Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    Multiple locations
  • 3611 18th St, Mission San Francisco, CA
  • Cafe Rustica, Cheap Eats Restaurants, Pizza, 5422 College Ave Oakland CA 94618
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    5422 College Ave, North Oakland Oakland, CA
  • Arizmendi Bakery & Pizzeria, Cheap Eats Restaurants, Pizza, 4301 San Pablo Ave Emeryville CA 94608
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    4301 San Pablo Ave, Emeryville, CA
  • Little Star Pizza, Cheap Eats, Great Meals, Food, Pizza, Italian, Gourmet Pizza, Bar Bites, Place for a Slice, Wings, 846 Divisadero St Western Addition/NoPa San Francisco CA 94117
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    846 Divisadero St, World Map San Francisco, CA
  • Tony's Pizza Napoletana, Cheap Eats, Food, Pizza, Place for Greasy Slice, Gourmet Pizza, Place for a Slice, 1570 Stockton St. North Beach/Telegraph Hill San Francisco CA 94133
    1570 Stockton St., North Beach/Telegraph Hill San Francisco, CA
  • Pizza Orgasmica & Brewing Company, Nightlife, Food, Brewpub, Gourmet Pizza, Place for Greasy Slice, 823 Clement St Inner Richmond San Francisco CA 94118
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    823 Clement St, Inner Richmond San Francisco, CA
  • Amici's, Food, Gourmet Pizza, 2200 Lombard St Marina San Francisco CA 94123
    11. Amici's
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    2200 Lombard St, Cow Hollow San Francisco, CA
  • Gialina, Cheap Eats Restaurants, Pizza, 2842 Diamond St San Francisco CA 94131
    12. Gialina
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    2842 Diamond St, Glen Park San Francisco, CA
  • flour + water, Great Meals, Food, Italian, Gourmet Pizza, 2401 Harrison St Mission San Francisco CA 94110
    Nominee for: Italian, Gourmet Pizza
    2401 Harrison St, Mission San Francisco, CA
  • Una Pizza Napoletana, Food, Great Meals, Gourmet Pizza, 210 11th Street SoMa San Francisco CA 94103
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    210 11th Street, SoMa San Francisco, CA
  • Location
    15. Ragazza
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    311 Divisadero St, San Francisco, CA
  • Porky's Pizza Palace, Food, Great Meals, Gourmet Pizza, Place for a Slice, 1221 Manor Blvd Alameda County San Leandro CA 94579
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    1221 Manor Blvd, San Leandro, CA
  • Pizzeria Picco, Cheap Eats, Food, Great Meals, Pizza, Gourmet Pizza, 320 Magnolia Avenue World Map Larkspur CA 94939
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    320 Magnolia Avenue, World Map Larkspur, CA
  • Location
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    3881 24th St, Noe Valley San Francisco, CA
  • Rotten City Pizza, Cheap Eats, Pizza, 6613 Hollis St Alameda County Emeryville CA 94608
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    6613 Hollis St, Emeryville, CA
  • Location
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    820 Sycamore Valley Rd W, Danville, CA
  • Location
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    2327 Blanding Avenue, Alameda, CA
  • Location
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    373 E Campbell Ave, Santa Clara County Campbell, CA
  • Frankie Johnnie & Luigi Too, Food, Great Meals, Gourmet Pizza, 939 W El Camino Real Santa Clara County Mountain View CA 94040
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    939 W El Camino Real, Santa Clara County Mountain View, CA
  • Location
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    211 23rd Ave, Outer Richmond San Francisco, CA
  • Tommaso's, Food, Gourmet Pizza, Italian, 1042 Kearny St Nob Hill San Francisco CA 94133
    Nominee for: Gourmet Pizza
    1042 Kearny St, Nob Hill San Francisco, CA
Contest Overview
  • 72,388
    Total Votes
  • 31,401
    Voters
  • 172
    Winners

The 2012 Bay Area A-List awards are based on more than 72,000 votes from local Bay Area-area experts.

See the full results →

Browse Categories
Get more from the Bay Area A-List
Sections
Arts and Entertainment
Automotive
Fitness
Food
Health and Beauty
Housewares
Local Flavor
Nightlife
Parenting 101
Pets
Shopping
Weddings
Wineries
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
Food Truck Fight
Microbrew Madness
Napa/Sonoma Winery Showdown
Sitemap
Information
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
About
The Bay Area A-List features more than 14,370 businesses competing for title of Bay Area's best.

Connect with Bay Area A-List

@BayAreaAlist