Seafood - Best of 2010

Published Jun 17, 2010

If it comes from the sea, these restaurants know how to serve it right! Who's the best?

2010 Winner

1. Spenger's Fresh Fish Grotto

Voters Love

"Since it was mentioned, it does seem awfully suspicious that there's nearly twenty 5 star reviews, all of them left by..." via MadScotsman

Find It
1919 Fourth St. Berkeley CA 94710
  • Spenger's Fresh Fish Grotto, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 1919 Fourth St. Berkeley CA 94710
    Nominee for: Seafood
    1919 Fourth St., Fourth Street Berkeley, CA
  • Crab Landing Seafood & Steakhouse, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood Steakhouse Sushi Traditional American Waterfront Dining Wine List, 260 Capistrano Rd Half Moon Bay CA 94019
    Nominee for: Seafood
    260 Capistrano Rd, Half Moon Bay, CA
  • Pacific Catch, Food, Seafood, California, 2027 Chestnut St Marina San Francisco CA 94123
    Nominee for: Seafood, California
    Multiple locations
  • Crab House, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 203 C Pier 39 San Francisco CA 94133
    Nominee for: Seafood
    203 C Pier 39, Fisherman's Wharf San Francisco, CA
  • Nominee for: Seafood
    1517 Polk St, Nob Hill San Francisco, CA
  • Catch, Great Meals Nightlife Restaurants, Brunch Neighborhood Bar Seafood Trendy Bar,     2362 Market St San Francisco CA 94114
    6. Catch
    Nominee for: Seafood
    Multiple locations
  • Farallon, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 450 Post St San Francisco CA 94102
    Nominee for: Seafood
    450 Post St, Union Square San Francisco, CA
  • McCormick & Kuleto's, Food, Seafood, 900 North Point Fisherman's Wharf San Francisco CA 94109
    Nominee for: Seafood
    900 North Point, Fisherman's Wharf San Francisco, CA
  • Walnut Creek Yacht Club, Great Meals, Food, Nightlife, Seafood, Speciailty Cocktails, Bar Bites, Specialty Cocktails, Fish Market, Craft Cocktails, Romantic Restaurant, Wine Bar, 1555 Bonanza St World Map Walnut Creek CA 94596
    Nominee for: Seafood
    1555 Bonanza St, World Map Walnut Creek, CA
  • Willi's Seafood and Raw Bar, Food, Seafood, Tapas, 403 Healdsburg Ave. Healdsburg CA
    Nominee for: Seafood
    403 Healdsburg Ave., Healdsburg, CA
  • Go Fish, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 641 Main St St Helena CA 94574
    9. Go Fish
    Nominee for: Seafood
    641 Main St, St Helena, CA
  • Waterbar, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 399 The Embarcadero San Francisco CA 94105
    12. Waterbar
    Nominee for: Seafood
    399 The Embarcadero, Embarcadero San Francisco, CA
  • Anchor & Hope, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 83 Minna St San Francisco CA 94105
    Nominee for: Seafood
    83 Minna St, SoMa San Francisco, CA
  • Nettie's Crab Shack, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 2032 Union St. San Francisco CA 94123
    Nominee for: Seafood
    2032 Union St., Cow Hollow San Francisco, CA
  • Sam's Grill, Food, Seafood, 374 Bush St Financial District San Francisco CA 94104
    Nominee for: Seafood
    374 Bush St, Financial District San Francisco, CA
  • Marica Seafood Restaurant, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 5301 College Ave Oakland CA 94618
    Nominee for: Seafood
    5301 College Ave, North Oakland Oakland, CA
  • Seasalt, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 2512 San Pablo Ave Berkeley CA 94702
    12. Seasalt
    Nominee for: Seafood
    2512 San Pablo Ave, Berkeley, CA
  • Pacific Cafe, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 850 College Ave Kentfield CA 94904
    Nominee for: Seafood
    850 College Ave, Kentfield, CA
  • Horatio's, Food, Seafood, 60 Monarch Bay Drive Alameda County San Leandro CA
    12. Horatio's
    Nominee for: Seafood
    60 Monarch Bay Drive, San Leandro, CA
  • Hayes Street Grill, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 320 Hayes St. San Francisco CA 94102
    Nominee for: Seafood
    320 Hayes St., Hayes Valley San Francisco, CA
  • Anchor Oyster Bar, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 579 Castro St. San Francisco CA 94114
    Nominee for: Seafood
    579 Castro St., Castro San Francisco, CA
  • Seafood Peddler, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 100 Yacht Club Dr San Rafael CA 94901
    Nominee for: Seafood
    100 Yacht Club Dr, San Rafael, CA
  • Alioto's, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, #8 Fisherman's Wharf San Francisco CA 94133
    12. Alioto's
    Nominee for: Seafood
    #8 Fisherman's Wharf, North Beach/Telegraph Hill San Francisco, CA
  • Scoma's Restaurant, Great Meals, Food, Seafood, Waterfront Dining, Pier 47 on Al Scoma Way SoMa San Francisco CA 94133
    Nominee for: Seafood
    Pier 47 on Al Scoma Way, World Map San Francisco, CA
  • Alamo Square Seafood Grill, Great Meals Restaurants, Seafood, 803 Fillmore St San Francisco CA 94117
    Nominee for: Seafood
    803 Fillmore St, Hayes Valley San Francisco, CA
Contest Overview
  • 70,811
    Total Votes
  • 81,457
  • 295

The 2010 Best of the BayList awards are based on more than 70,000 votes from local Bay Area-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the Bay Area A-List
Arts and Entertainment
Cheap Eats
Daily Services
Great Meals
Home Goods
Kitchen and Bath
Lawn and Garden
Out and Active
Outdoor Living
Repair Services
Specialty Food and Drink
Sports Supplies
Wine Country
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
Food Truck Fight
Microbrew Madness
Napa/Sonoma Winery Showdown
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
The Bay Area A-List features more than 14,371 businesses competing for title of Bay Area's best.

Connect with Bay Area A-List